Cool and Unusual Punishment

This week on the podcast, Jodie has a missing person’s case with a million leads and a real lack of follow-up. Then, Tyler talks about the “custom of the sea” and whether or not Edgar Allan Poe is a prophetic genius. This week’s episode brought to you by blueberry vodka that goes down frighteningly smooth.

It’s a new year and C&UP has found new ways to get weird. First, Tyler tells a beautiful, decades-long love story involving swords and gentlemanly custom. Then, Jodie has got a Wisconsin murder for the ages that has all the ingredients of a good caper: dismemberment, love triangles, and rubber stamps.

This week’s episode brought to you by a growler of Warped Speed!

Cool & Unusual comes to you this week with blistering festive energy fueled by cheap beer! Tyler brings the story of Dr. Brinkley, the man who almost took over the world with goat testicles. Then, we look to the skies for ominous signs of danger as Jodie brings firsthand accounts of the mythical, benevolent beast that is Mothman.

This week on the podcast, Jodie brings a not-so-cold-case that was in our right in our backyard, and it is up to us to decide which Munster may have done it. Then, Tyler drags everybody down the terrible, traumatic rabbit hole of Youtube kids and ends up drunk, confused and scared.

This week on the punishment, Tyler has brought along extensive training resources on becoming a certified exorcist. What does the course load look like and what are the chances we end up paying for it ironically? Also, Jodie has a grisly campground story where everybody involved gets everything wrong at absolutely every step of the way.

This week’s episode is brought to you by Milkshake Malt Porter and Emily Post’s thoughts on American’s abroad!

Apologies for exactly one half of an episode this week! One of our co-hosts took a bathroom break before the second story and he managed to not turn the recorder back on before he told what almost certainly was an incredible story. We do however, have some weird takes on Craigslist ads, Jeremy Renner’s most ardent fanbase, and a Wisconsin story so spooky it made an episode of Unsolved Mysteries! We will be back soon and we will be sure to check that the red light is on next time!

This week Tyler and Jodie are spanning the breadth of time to bring you both a tuberculosis riddled tale of love and revenge in the Wild West, as well as an infamous modern day athlete whose incredible talents unfortunately did not include telling a believable lie. This week’s episode is brought to you simple, biblical baby names.

We are back from a hectic week of moving and returning to the microphones to be cool and unusual once again! This week, Jodie has oracle cards in hand and a story about the son of an infamous cult leader who MAY OR MAY NOT live here in Wisconsin, and Tyler wants to tell you about a man who’s strange 30 year career has all led him towards the righteous duty of hunting aliens.

This week on the show, we did not go to a haunted house, so we instead tell stories of Halloween switch-a-roos before diving into the deep end. Tyler would like to tell you some advice on how to survive falling from a plane without a parachute, and Jodie has a story that proves the weirdest thing about Frank Lloyd Wright isn’t his architecture.